Picture the cover of a romance novel in your head. There’s probably some piratical guy sweeping a woman in a sheer white dress off her feet and into his arms. But what’s the guy wearing? If he’s not totally shirtless, he’s probably wearing an old-timey henley completely open in order to show his excellent pecs.

There’s something inherently sexy about this kind of swash-buckling repro shirt and Pike Brothers definitely brings the heat. Their 1923 Buccaneer Shirt is 100% cotton and based on a formal European shirt from the 1920s. This versatile slim fit shirt can totally be worn at any number of fancy events, but unbutton the coconut buttons on that collar and take to the high seas. It’s time for you to be the Fabio-esque sex-pirate you never knew you wanted to be.

Available for $139 at Cultizm.